Jobless Recovery Remains, Despite Statistical Hype


by Fred Goldstein
March 6, 2011

The big business press and TV is hyping the February job numbers as evidence of a coming turnaround in the recovery of jobs. The government announced that 192,000 net new jobs were created last month and that the private sector created 222,000 jobs. Thus, the unemployment rate was declared to have gone down from 9.0 percent to 8.9 percent.

But no matter how much hype is mustered behind these figures, no matter how much the pundits read good news into a miserable situation, the jobless recovery continues without letup.

The Wall Street Journal, of all publications, lifted the lid on the truth that is concealed in the current statistics.

[O]ne key gauge of the labor market’s health—the labor force participation rate, which measures the percentage of adults who have jobs or are seeking them—remained stuck at its lowest point since the mid-1980s.

A low participation rate both saps the economy’s long-term growth potential and can obscure deeper problems in the labor market. If, for example, labor force participation today were at the same level as before the recession, the jobless rate would have been 11.5% in February.

In other words, no matter how the government slices and dices the statistics, millions of workers have given up looking for jobs long ago and the statisticians of the capitalist government have no desire to count them. Thus they do not enter into the calculations of the unemployment rate.

The economy has officially added an average of 136,000 jobs per month since November. According to the Economic Policey Institute (EPI), which bases its numbers on the Bureau of Labor Statistics, it takes 127,000 per month just to keep up with new entries into the labor force.

Considering that there are 13.7 million people officially unemployed, around 8 million under-employed and over 2 million are officially counted as having dropped out, at the present pace of job growth, there will not be a dent in mass unemployment. By one calculation from the Center for American Progress, a liberal think tank, it would take until 2033 just to get back to 5 percent unemployment!

While there was much crowing about the pitiful figure of 222,000 jobs added in the private sector, there was no report on how many of them are temporary jobs, low-wage jobs, short-hour jobs. The bosses have adopted a “just-in-time” hiring policy of temporary workers who can be disposed of at any moment.

Furthermore, it was quietly stated that state and local governments laid off 30,000 workers in February. States have cut 82,000 jobs and localities have cut 377,000 jobs since August 2008. And unless the working class can stop these state and local governments and the bankers and bosses behind them, the plan is to escalate layoffs of public sector workers.

The capitalist state, the Federal Reserve, the Treasury Department and the White House have pumped $10 trillion dollars into the economy, mostly to bail out the banks, the auto industry, and in loan guarantees. At the end of it all, there are around 30 million workers still unemployed, underemployed or who have dropped out and are totally unaccounted for in the government statistics.

Bankers’ profits are higher than ever. Corporate profits are up. The capitalists are recoverving, but for the tens of millions of workers it is still a jobless recovery.

What is a jobless recovery? It is a recovery of business production and profits while jobs either continue to be lost, or whatever gains take place are minimal. Under capitalism historically business recoveries are supposed to be accompanied by an upsurge in hiring, not job losses or job stagnation.

The first jobless recovery in the U.S. since the Great Depression followed the recession of 1991. This was followed by a second and much worse one after the 2000-2001 downturn. What the U.S. working class is experiencing today is the third consecutive jobless recovery only this one is far more severe, for more protracted, and shows little sign of abating at all.

Capitalism has hit an impasse. The more productive it becomes, the fewer workers it needs and the lower wages it pays.

The class struggle of the workers to keep the ruling class from unloading on them this huge debt crisis that was incurred by bailing out the millionaires and billionaires and to fight for jobs is the only way out.

The workers in Wisconsin and all the workers around the country who have rallied to their cause have set in motion a movement which must grow and spread so that it can become the spark that lights the fire of mass fight back to turn the capitalist recovery into a working class recovery.



About B.J. Murphy

I'm a young socialist and Transhumanist activist within the East Coast region, who writes for the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies (IEET), India Future Society, and Serious Wonder. I'm also the Social Media Manager for Serious Wonder, an Advisory Board Member for the Lifeboat Foundation, and a Co-Editor for Fight Back! News.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s